Should You Stay Friends with Your Ex? A Therapist’s Guide to Finding Your Own Answer

"Should I stay friends with my ex?"

It's a question that comes up constantly in therapy. Sometimes, clients ask me directly, their voices full of uncertainty. More often, it's an unasked question, hovering in the air as they sheepishly mention a recent coffee or text exchange, as if bracing for judgment.

The simple answer is that there is no one-size-fits-all response. A post-breakup friendship can be a source of profound comfort and connection for some, and a painful, enmeshed trap for others.

So, how can you know what's right for you? This guide won't give you a simple "yes" or "no." Instead, it will offer you a set of tools — a framework for reflection — to help you find your own honest answer.

First, a Crucial Distinction: Being "Friendly" vs. Being "Friends"

Before we go any further, we need to be clear about what we're talking about. There is a huge difference between being friendly with an ex and being friends with them.

• Being Friendly is about striving for civility, kindness, and mutual respect. For relationships with shared logistics — co-parenting, business ties, legal issues — friendliness is often a healthy and necessary goal. It's about managing interactions with grace.

• Being Friends implies something much deeper. Friendship involves intimacy, comfort, and emotional support. A friend is someone you can call in a tight spot, someone with whom you share a sense of safety and reliability.

Striving for friendliness with an ex is almost always a good idea (unless safety is a concern). Deciding to be friends, however, is a much bigger and more complicated question.

The Arguments You've Already Heard

You've probably debated this with your own friends. The arguments are well-worn.

• The Argument Against: Staying friends is a sign you haven't properly moved on. It's a way of holding onto the past, creating an enmeshed relationship with unhealthy boundaries that prevents both of you from truly healing.

• The Argument For: You were in a relationship for a reason; you have deep chemistry and a shared history. A friendship with an ex can be one of the most honest and powerful you'll ever have.

The truth is, both of these arguments can be correct. This is why a simple pro/con list will never be enough to give you clarity. We need to go deeper.

The Core Question: A Thought Experiment for Radical Clarity

If you are feeling stuck and confused, I want you to try this thought experiment. It is designed to cut through the noise of your history, your obligations, and what you think you should do, and get to the heart of what is true for you right now.

Step 1: Get in Touch with the Full Feeling
Take a moment to sit quietly and think about your ex. Allow yourself to feel the entire, complex cocktail of emotions that comes up. Don't censor it. It might be warmth and appreciation. It might also be anger, guilt, disappointment, or a lingering sense of sadness. Notice all of it without judgment.

Step 2: Ask the Question
Once you have a clear sense of that emotional mixture, ask yourself this:

If I met a stranger tomorrow, and I knew that every single time I was with them, they would make me feel exactly like this… would I want to be their friend?

Would you willingly invite that entire emotional experience — the good, the bad, and the complicated — into your life on a regular basis?

Step 3: Listen to Your Gut
Your immediate, gut-level answer to that question is your truth. Our shared history and our sense of obligation can keep us tethered to relationships that are no longer healthy for the people we are today. This exercise isn't about judging your ex as a "good" or "bad" person. It is about being radically honest with yourself about their impact on your emotional well-being now.

From Reflection to Action: The Power of Boundaries

Your answer to that question will guide your next steps.

• If your answer was "No": That's a clear sign that you need space. This doesn't mean you have to cut off all contact forever, especially if there are logistical ties. But it does mean that a true friendship, with its demands of intimacy and support, is not a healthy choice for you at this time.

• If your answer was "Yes, but…": This is where boundaries become essential. Perhaps you value their presence, but the intensity of the connection is too much. You can choose to redefine the friendship. This might look like seeing each other less frequently, or deciding that certain topics are off-limits.

A true friendship is a source of nourishment, not a constant drain. The fear of setting a boundary is often a sign that the relationship isn't a balanced friendship at all, but an echo of an old, unhealthy dynamic.

A final thought: As a general rule, it is almost always healthy to take a period of space and limited social contact after a breakup. This allows both people time to heal and recalibrate. A healthy friendship, if it's meant to be, will flourish best when it is not born from a sense of urgency, guilt, or a fear of letting go.

Give yourself time. Listen to your gut. And trust yourself to know what you truly need.